Well it's my turn to lead the Roundtable discussion once again. I think in honor of the passing of Jerry Falwell today's topic should be hate.
When I found out that Falwell died yesterday I was giddy. It was like a colon cancer had been cut out of the world, albeit much later than it should have been as the disease of bigotry and intolerance has spread to so many other vital organs, most notably the White House. I expressed out loud to several people how happy I was he was gone and that I was glad to learn that he died alone and I hoped it hurt and he was scared. Pretty much all the same stuff I wrote in yesterday's post.
Many people greeted my statement with the same twisted chuckle I had. There are others who are aghast at saying something so mean about someone who just died, even if he was a total douche bag.
Others will say that you shouldn't celebrate the death of someone. But a lot of these same people are the ones who would cheer the killing of Osama bin Laden. A dead religious fanatic is a dead religious fanatic, and it's a good thing either way. I don't support killing people, not even the death penalty for criminals, but I don't have any problem with celebrating the death of an evil person.
I got into an argument one time with some namby-pamby Christian type who told me that hate was always a bad emotion and I should love more. I told him that was bullshit. Hate is a human emotion like any other and it can be positive or negative. I gave him one easy example.
I hate war.
Nothing wrong with that kind of hate. And if you think it's wrong to hate war, well you got problems and your name is probably Dick Cheney.
Sure, lots of hate can be bad. The hatred that Hitler and the Nazis had for the Jews was terrible. The hate that caused the lynchings of countless black Americans by the KKK or their supporters over the years is revolting. The hatred of homosexuals by religious conservatives has led to the current spewing of nonsense by politicians like Mitt Romney and our idiot president that gay people are a threat to traditional marriage, which has in turn led to a rise in violence against gays and lesbians around the country. That hate has also led to the likes of people like Fred Phelps blaming the victims of those violent crimes for what has happened to them. He's the guy who led protesters at Matthew Shepard's funeral holding up signs like "God Hates Fags."
But hate can be used for good. Morris Dees hates racism and intolerance. He turned that hate into the Southern Poverty Law Center that works to fight against bigotry in all its forms. That hate has led to a major weakening of the Klan and other neo-Nazi groups.
I know that some of you are thinking, "But Deni, isn't the kind of venom you're spewing about people like Jerry Falwell just as bad as the hate they spread for women and gays?"
No, it's not. If you can't see the difference I just feel sorry for you. Think of it as this example. Hitler hating the Jews? Bad. Hating Hitler? Good.
So I'm OK with the hate that I have. I hate bigots. I hate gay bashers. I hate child molesters. I hate rapists. And I hate people like Jerry Falwell and those who follow them.
So the Roundtable questions this week are these. How do you feel about hate? Who do you hate? Even if you haven't said it out loud, isn't there someone who has died and your first thought about them was "good riddance?"
Be honest now.
Let me have your thoughts.
Everything Bagel pt. 2
1 week ago
12 comments:
Wow, politics AND religion -- the only two subjects we (or at least I) would rather avoid at our friendly little weekly roundtables...
I'll be over at the bar... good luck!
Well, it's not really about politics and religion. It's about things one hates, it can be any subject you want.
Like how you may hate people who talk about politics and religion.
Well, I'm never actually sure how I feel about the death penalty. I waffle back and forth, with the pendulum mostly swinging towards "Agin' It". But I I've gotta say, I was fairly happy when Jeffrey Dahmer bit it.
Well sure, but Dahmer wasn't actually executed, he was killed by a fellow inmate. He wasn't even on death row.
See Joe, I told you I could walk into the Roundtable room and create an awkward, uncomfortable silence.
I'm a man of many talents. But mainly that one.
I hate when I have a paper cut in the webbing of my fingers and then I pour lemon juice on it. oooh, I hate when that happens!
TBO, don't pour lemon juice on it then.
I hate the word "bespoke."
See Beige, that really is the kind of thing that only happens to you.
Ooh yea Sereena, bespoke is a crappy word. I also hate the word arguably.
I hate the use of "impact" as a verb. Even worse than that is "impactful."
And I hate the Yankees, Cowboys, Spurs and Rangers.
Oh, and peaches. I hate peaches.
I hate Cheney, Rumsfeld, every Bush ever, Tim Eyman, Boomer Esiason, Ann Coulter, Dan Dierdorf, Celine Dion, and the American version of "Iron Chef."
And, of course, the Dutch.
I think it's fine to hate, but it's dangerous to use the hateful emotion too easily. I may say I hate people who talk on their cell phone while driving, but I don't really hate them. I do it occasionally too.
But then to hate those that hate is a bit contradictory. Perhaps we should try to convince those that we hate that they should believe otherwise, but that rarely works.
Hating something that is evil is fine, but then where is the line between just bad and evil?
I know I've asked more questions than personal answers, but in a nutshell, it's OK to hate, but hate sparingly and make sure what you hate is really bad.
JJ, I (heart) anyone who hates the Yankees.
As a Cleveland Indians fan, I hate the Yankees too. Not real hate, just sports hate. OK, maybe a little more than that.
ok, now that I've had a few beverages I guess I'll throw my 2 cents in...
I mean, it's one thing to hate the Yankees, or the weather, or car commercials, or whatever...
But the kind of hate that results in feeling truly happy about the death of another person -- even if it's a horrible dictator or some two-bit fundamentalist asshole -- does nothing to resolve the underlying reasons why hateful people like that attain power and influence in the first place.
And the ability to hate your enemies to the point of wishing them dead is fundamental to the entire war mindset -- kill enough of the bad guys and the problem will be solved. It's a "just cause." Hating war and yet hating one's enemies so much that you want them to die seems to be a conflict...
As Atul wisely says, hate is perhaps inevitable, but dangerous... something to be avoided, even if it seems justified. Disagree, dislike, oppose... but to hate -- and to relish in another's demise -- is a risky line to cross.
All you need is love, dude... (and another drink...)
peace, love, and swizzle sticks...
Post a Comment